-

“Wait… I Have to Pay Overtime on Commission?”



By Purciarele Group

If you’ve ever caught yourself thinking,

“But they’re commission… I don’t owe overtime, right?”

You’re not alone.

It’s one of the most common—and most expensive—mistakes I see business owners make.

Where the confusion starts

Commission feels different.

It’s not hourly.
It’s not salary.
It’s tied to performance.

So it’s easy to assume that overtime doesn’t apply.

But wage and hour laws don’t work based on what “feels logical.”
They work based on classification and compliance.

The Myth: “Commission = No Overtime”

The misunderstanding usually sounds like this:

  • “They’re 100% commission, so they’re basically running their own book of business.”
  • “They’re making great money—overtime shouldn’t apply.”
  • “My last company did it this way for years and never had a problem.”

Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), how someone is paid does not determine whether overtime is owed.

The law is much simpler than people expect:

👉 If an employee is non-exempt and works more than 40 hours in a workweek, overtime is due.

And yes—
👉 That includes commission.

Commission is part of earnings.
It is not a workaround.

What Actually Drives Overtime Obligations

Three things matter far more than pay structure:

1. Job duties
Does the role truly meet an exemption test (executive, administrative, professional, outside sales), or is it hands-on, structured work?

2. Exempt vs. non-exempt classification
Most frontline roles—even high-performing ones—are non-exempt.

3. Hours worked
Overtime is based on a 7-day workweek.
Not pay periods. Not averages.

If someone works 47 hours in a week, those 7 overtime hours exist—whether you track them properly or not.

For Florida employers, this is straightforward:
👉 The state follows federal FLSA rules. There is no special carve-out for commission.

So When Can Commissioned Employees Be Exempt?

There is a very narrow exception under the FLSA called the 7(i) exemption (retail or service exemption).

To qualify, all three must be true:

  • The business qualifies as a retail or service establishment
  • The employee’s regular rate exceeds 1.5× minimum wage in overtime weeks
  • More than 50% of earnings come from commissions over a representative period

If even one of these is not met:

👉 The employee is non-exempt
👉 Overtime applies

This is where many businesses think they qualify—but can’t actually support it if challenged.

How Overtime Actually Works With Commission

This is where things get missed most often.

If a commissioned employee is non-exempt:

Step 1: Add up total weekly earnings (including commission)
Step 2: Divide by total hours worked → this is the regular rate
Step 3: Pay an additional 0.5× regular rate for each hour over 40

Example:

  • Weekly commission: $1,200
  • Hours worked: 50
  • Regular rate: $1,200 ÷ 50 = $24/hour
  • Overtime hours: 10

Overtime premium:
10 × (0.5 × $24) = $120

👉 Total pay = $1,200 + $120 = $1,320

If you’re not running this calculation, there’s likely a gap.

⚠️ Why this becomes a problem fast

This isn’t the kind of issue that shows up right away.

It shows up later—when:

  • Someone leaves
  • Someone gets frustrated
  • Someone starts asking questions

And by the time it shows up, you’re not fixing payroll…
you’re fixing exposure.

Common Ways Employers Get Into Trouble

This usually isn’t intentional. It comes from:

  • “We’ve always paid straight commission”
  • “They make good money already”
  • “We don’t track hours for commission roles”
  • “We assumed we qualified for the exemption”

But when records aren’t there—or calculations weren’t done correctly—
👉 That’s when back pay, penalties, and claims start adding up.

Why You May Not Hear About It Right Away

Commission roles often delay problems because:

  • Paychecks are strong
  • Employees don’t question it immediately
  • Issues surface when someone leaves or something changes

And when they do:

👉 Employees may look back 2–3 years (or more) for unpaid overtime.

Questions Every Business Should Be Asking Right Now

If you have commission-based roles:

  • Are these roles truly exempt based on duties—not just pay?
  • Are we tracking all hours worked?
  • Are we including commission in the regular rate?
  • Are we calculating overtime correctly every week?

If using the 7(i) exemption:

  • Can we prove we qualify as a retail/service business?
  • Can we show regular rate exceeds 1.5× minimum wage?
  • Do we have documentation that >50% of earnings are commission?

If the answer isn’t clearly “yes” with documentation—
it’s worth a closer look.

What Getting It Right Looks Like

For most businesses, it comes down to:

  • Clear classification decisions
  • Accurate time tracking
  • Proper payroll calculations
  • Transparent compensation plans

Not complicated—just intentional.

💬 Final Thought

Most businesses aren’t trying to get this wrong.

They just don’t realize there’s more to it—until there is.

Commission can absolutely work.
But it has to be structured correctly.

Because when it’s not…
it’s not just a payroll issue.

It’s a liability.

🚨 Now What

If you have commission-based employees and you’re not completely confident in how overtime is being handled, it’s time to address it.

This is not an area to guess on or revisit later.

At Purciarele Group, we work with businesses to:

  • Review classification and pay structures
  • Identify gaps and risk areas
  • Implement clean, compliant, and sustainable processes

So you can operate confidently—without wondering if something is going to come back later.

📌 Let’s get it right

If you want your pay practices reviewed and structured correctly, reach out to us info@purciarelegroup.com  https://purciarelegroup.com/contact-us/

We love HR so you don’t have to®️

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HR Red Flags You're Ignoring—Until It's Too Late

-
Image
HR Red Flags You're Ignoring—Until It's Too Late By Purciarele Group – HR Simplified! Some business problems announce themselves with sirens. Others start with a whisper: a missed deadline, a frustrated employee, an awkward silence in a meeting. Too often, leaders dismiss these as “normal growing pains” or “people stuff that will work itself out.” Spoiler alert: it won’t. And by the time you're forced to act, it’s already cost you— in morale, productivity, reputation, or turnover. We've seen it all. These five HR red flags are the quiet killers of great teams. And if you're seeing any of them? It's time to stop ignoring and start addressing. 🚩 1. Your Best Employee Has Gone Quiet They used to take initiative, offer ideas, and mentor others. Now? They’re doing the bare minimum, logging off early, or making passive comments like, “I’m just keeping my head down these days.” What it really means: Disengagement is setting in. They’ve lost trust in lea...
Read more

HR & the Spirit of Summer

-
Image
 ☀️ HR & the Spirit of Summer: Bringing a Little Sunshine Back to the Workplace Do you remember what June used to feel like? The countdown to the last day of school. The sound of flip-flops smacking against the pavement. Ice cream trucks blaring their music down suburban streets. Sleepovers. Sprinklers. Fireflies. Long days at the pool followed by even longer nights of freedom. Summer wasn’t just a season—it was a feeling. Then… you grew up. And June became just another month on the calendar—packed with meetings, deadlines, and quarterly goals. Summer break turned into “business as usual,” with the whimsy buried under piles of paperwork, overflowing inboxes, and calendars blocked from 9 to 5. But what if summer didn’t have to vanish? What if we could bring some of that childhood magic back—right into the workplace? As an HR consulting firm that partners with businesses across the country, we hear the same thing over and over again from leaders and employees alike: burnout does...
Read more

Unmasking Passive Toxicity Before It Undermines Your Culture

-
Image
The Most Dangerous Person in Your Workplace Might Be ‘Nice’ Unmasking Passive Toxicity Before It Undermines Your Culture When you hear “toxic employee,” you probably picture someone who yells, resists authority, or blatantly pushes boundaries. They’re disruptive, loud, and unmistakable. But there’s another kind of toxicity—one that’s far more dangerous because it hides in plain sight. It’s the employee who smiles in meetings, avoids conflict, and presents as “easygoing” or “supportive.” They’re often described as nice —and on the surface, they probably are. But dig deeper, and you may discover that this same person is quietly derailing your team through passive-aggressive behaviors, manipulation, or strategic avoidance. This is passive toxicity —and it can do just as much damage, if not more, than overt misconduct. What Passive Toxicity Looks Like This kind of behavior doesn’t always leave obvious footprints, but over time, it corrodes trust, collaboration, and performance. You...
Read more